Go to homepage
George Bernard Shaw in "The Genuine Islam": I have studied him (The Prophet Muhammad) the wonderful man and in my opinion he must be called the saviour of humanity.
Latest Announcements:
Welcome to this new site, aimed at explaining Islam accurately for non-Muslims
List All Articles
Download Pack of 26 Leaflets
Search Articles:
What Muslims Believe
Islam Explained
An Invitation to Think
Challenging Myths
Decrease Text Size ="Increase
The Quran cannot be compared to the Bible
Sebastian Faulks this week wrote of his disappointment at the 'one dimensional' stories of the Quran compared to those of the Bible. His interview with the Sunday Times also saw him call the Quran "a depressing book", which is "one-dimensional", with "no ethical dimension like the New Testament, no new plan for life". He said later "it is fair to say the New Testament is the most ethically sophisticated of the great scriptures, the proper comparison for the Qur'an is with the Old Testament against which it holds its own. I accept that the ethics of Islam have been developed by scholars and thinkers over the centuries, and in the course of that time have become the equal of other religions in their sophistication."

However, in all of this Sebastian Faulks is making a common, but grave error. The Quran and the Bible cannot not be compared.

The Bible could be more properly compared to what in Islam is called 'Seerah' - the life of The Prophet Muhammad - as both of these are based upon the reports of followers of their respective prophets , whether Jewish, Christian or Muslim. Such reports need checking for accuracy, and in this only the Islamic reports have been meticulously recorded with their chains of narration and biographies of the narrators. The biblical reports, both old and new testaments, cannot be verified for their authenticity.

The Quran, on the other hand, is the unchanged, uncorrupted direct word of Allah (God), memorised and written down by so many of The Prophet Muhammad 's companions that its authenticity is irrefutable. Furthermore, it is a miracle in itself, as its language could never have come from any but Allah. (See article The Quran's Challenge)

It is far too common that writers fail to check the facts before commenting on the Quran. The stories contained in the Quran are similar to those of the Bible, because Islam is the final chapter in a continuing revelation to the previous prophets .

"And this Quran is could not have been authored by other than Allah, but it is a verification of that which was before it and a detailed scripture, there is no doubt in it, from the Lord of the worlds." (Quran chapter 10, verse 37)

The Quran was revealed in Arabic, so it will inevitably lose its superior literary qualities when rendered into English. Such outstanding literary excellence can actually move both reciter and listener to tears, while recounting the same or similar stories.

"And We have indeed illustrated examples of all kinds in this Quran, so that they may ponder. The Quran in Arabic, having no deviation at all, so that they may be pious." (Quran chapter 39, verses 27 and 28)

Muslims do not rely solely on the Quran to understand the Quran. Some parts of the Quran explain other parts, while sometimes it is the words of The Prophet that explain verses of the Quran. Some Muslim scholars have even taken to the Jewish scriptures themselves to help give more detailed explanations of the Quran, with the condition that they did not contradict the Quran. If any contradiction occurred, the older scriptures were rejected, as their authenticity could not be verified, whereas the Quran's authenticity can be. Muslims read from such explanations (called tafsir) and do not attempt to deduce their way of life solely from the text of the Quran.

After Sebastian's comments, BBC Radio 4 invited Fay Weldon to give her opinion on both the stories of
the Bible and the Quran. No opportunity was lost to further attack Islam in this interview, regardless of the facts. Rather than focus on the questions asked to her, Fay Weldon could not resist recommending that readers of the Quran skip any verses that refer to women , as "they are quite frightening", giving "no respect to women ".

This could not be further from the truth. Islam gave women rights when women were totally disregarded. The pagan Arabs had no interest in women ; they did not even bother to keep relations with relatives from the mother's side. The Quran emphasises that people are from male and female, and criticises the wrongdoers for not keeping relations with maternal relatives. The Quran gave women status. We reject the idea that Islam view women as inferior; a more detailed explanation of women in Islam can be read in the article women under the Shariah

The questions remains though, what are the values and rights that Fay Weldon believes the Quran has ignored for women ? Her unqualified and cheap attack failed to provide any explanation. Perhaps she was referring to the right to beaten up, as domestic violence increases in secular Britain. (see news article [1] )
Or does she particularly treasure the British women 's right to be insulted by her country men? Such insults are borne out of her depressingly low status as an object to sell products, or satisfy the desires of lusty men [2]. A woman today has very little respect and is viewed as little more than a piece of meat. If she hasn't got the right look, then her value is severely diminished, and she knows it, hence the enormous diet, fashion and beauty industries. (see news article [3])
Perhaps Fay is pleased with the new trend that young women must now compete with men in every field, even in promiscuity [4] and drinking them under the table. (see news article [5])
It could be that Fay is just complaining that Islam did not give women the right to feel pressured into choosing between being poor with kids, or comfortable but childless. Islam does not expect mothers to juggle a career and parenting, with the children increasingly being neglected. (see news article [6])

Islam gives the women dignity. She is a person and not an object. She has the right to work, but not to be exploited for her body. She has the right to be a mother and have the financial stability to raise children properly. She is an honour, whose violation, whether verbal or physical, will not be encouraged nor tolerated.

Perhaps those who attack the Quran without any real understanding of it should spend a little more time thinking and a little less time throwing stones especially when their own houses are so obviously made of glass.


[1] New powers to deal with domestic violence, The North West Evening Mail, 26/8/2009

[2] Our culture is infected with porn, Sandrine Levque, guardian.co.uk, Friday 24 Apri 2009

[3] Fiona Bruce: 'If you look like the back end of a bus, you won't get the job.', The Guardian, 26/8/2009

[4] Teen pregnancy rates go back up, BBC online, 26/2/2009

[5] Ladette binge-drinking violence soars by 300% in just seven years, The Mail online, 26/8/2009

[6] Family breakdown damaging children, say Tories, The Telegraph, 26/8/2009


CAPTCHA Image Type text on the left in this box: Reload Image
Categories: Challenging Myths, | Tags: Bible, Quran,

The following articles are also linked to this article:
children, values: The Case of Baby P: Is Britain Broken? "This newspaper has never shared David Cameron's view that Britain is a 'broken society'. But we do believe that this country has broken communities. The story of Baby P provides a glim...
values, children: Society's Individualism Damages Children The wellbeing of millions of children across Britain is being damaged by adults' aggressive pursuit of personal success, a three-year inquiry by the Children's Society concluded in February ...
miracle: The Qurans Challenge And if you doubt any part of what We have revealed, upon Our servant [Muhammad], then produce a surah of its like, and call upon any other than Allah to bear witness for you - if what you say is true...
women: Women under the Shariah? It is widely believed in the West that Islam subjugates women. Many believe that men force women to cover their hair, to stay at home chained to the stove, that women should remain uneducated and weak...
Shariah: Is there any good example of a state that implements Shariah today? With so much talk about Shariah in the news, a natural question to ask is Is there a Muslim country which implements Shariah now? Tabloid newspapers often say that if Muslims dont like living in th...
Shariah: What is Shariah? When the Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams, head of the Anglican Church, suggested that some aspects of Shariah law should be incorporated into British law a tirade of criticism was launched at ...
secular: Islam and Secularism Democracy is a system of government where political power is said to be held by the people and exercised by citizens through their elected representatives. As humans make mistakes, it is considered th...
prophets: What are the main things Muslims believe? A Muslim believes in Allah (the Arabic name referring to God); that nothing other than Allah is worthy of worship, and that Muhammad was His final Prophet.A Muslim does not pray to Muhammad nor belie...
Muhammad, The Prophet: The Final Prophet "The Messenger believes in what has been revealed to him from his Lord, as do the believers. Each one of them believes in God, His angels, His books, and His Messengers. They say: 'We make no dis...
prophets: Prophets and Messengers If a human being realises that all things in the Universe, including humanity, are created matter created by a Creator that still does not explain how to live our lives.Across the centuries and co...
chapter: Can the Quran be translated? The Quran was sent down in the Arabic language from Allah to Muhammad with the angel Jibreel (Gabriel) as the messenger. It is the direct speach of Allah , so it cannot be considered Allah's wor...
miracle: Miracles: Mythical stories or signs of God? Secular philosophy and science in modern times have increased the scepticism by which people view stories of miracles. Natural explanations are sought for all things or else reports of the event are m...
Various symobols or Arabic text appear on these pages, e.g. and . If you would like to know their meaning, please click here.
If you have a question or comment, then please contact us. Not all emails will be answered, however, if your comments lend themselves to serious debate, then you should expect a reply within a few days.
Cached: 27/8/2009 at 17:34